2024: Gastón Brugman (LA Galaxy)
2023: Cucho Hernández (Columbus Crew)
2022: John McCarthy (Los Angeles FC)
2021: Sean Johnson (New York City FC)
2020: Lucas Zelarayán (Columbus Crew)
2019: Victor Rodriguez (Seattle Sounders FC)
2018: Josef Martínez (Atlanta United FC)
2017: Jozy Altidore (Toronto FC)
2016: Stefan Frei (Seattle Sounders FC)
2015: Diego Valeri (Portland Timbers)
2014: Robbie Keane (LA Galaxy)
2013: Aurélien Collin (Sporting Kansas City)
2012: Omar González (LA Galaxy)
2011: Landon Donovan (LA Galaxy)
2010: Conor Casey (Colorado Rapids)
2009: Nick Rimando (Real Salt Lake)
2008: Guillermo Barros Schelotto (Columbus Crew)
2007: Dwayne De Rosario (Houston Dynamo FC)
2006: Brian Ching (Houston Dynamo FC)
2005: Guillermo Ramirez (LA Galaxy)
2004: Alecko Eskandarian (D.C. United)
2003: Landon Donovan (San Jose Earthquakes)
2002: Carlos Ruiz (LA Galaxy)
2001: Dwayne De Rosario (San Jose Earthquakes)
2000: Tony Meola (Kansas City Wizards)
1999: Ben Olsen (D.C. United)
1998: Peter Nowak (Chicago Fire FC)
1997: Jaime Moreno (D.C. United)
1996: Marco Etcheverry (D.C. United)